It is pretty common if you are a pastor of a church or the director of a nonprofit to not enjoy fundraising. You didn’t go into ministry to ask for money. You went into ministry to change lives and make the world a better place.
In the video, I give you some thoughts on how to prepare yourself to be better at fundraising. You already know you need to fundraise, but, whenever you have the choice between connecting with donors or “doing real ministry,” which one do you choose? Here some things to think about:
#1 – Why is giving to your ministry important?
Can you point to specific ways that the world is better because your ministry exists? Think about this both in terms of the big picture as well as specific examples. Our local Humane Society just kicked off a capital campaign. Can you think of an actual dog that went from being on the streets to being a beloved pet? Do you know how many cats and dogs went from the streets to homes? What are the benefits to the community of having a place for stray animals? Spend some time considering this.
#2 – How has giving to your ministry impacted the lives of donors?
It would be worthwhile to just have this conversation with some key donors. What drives them to give and volunteer? How do they feel about their giving? Most people want to be part of something that is making an impact on the world, and I bet you will hear that in their stories. Actually hearing these stories will help you overcome the hesitation of engaging with donors.
#3 – Carve out some time for fundraising
Ministry will consume all the time you can afford to give it. Even more time than you can afford to give it. Ministry also will not fall apart if you carve out a day or an afternoon each week specifically to connect with donors. In fact, quite the opposite. Many ministries slowly go broke because this is neglected. Depending the ministry, here are things you can do:
- Categorize your Donors: Who are your core donors and volunteers? Who would you feel sick of they no longer supported your ministry? Those are in your A tier. Who are the next level…your B tier? They give or volunteer but you can tell they are not as committed to the ministry. Everyone else can go in your C tier. They have some connection to your ministry but their support is haphazard and can’t be counted on.
- Plan for A Tier: Schedule meetings or make calls to those on your A Tier. Hand write thank you notes when they give or serve. Are you giving them special treatment? Yes, because they are giving your ministry special treatment! Not acknowledging someone that is doing a good thing through their giving and serving makes them feel ignored or taken for granted.
- Plan for B Tier: This group is the group that won’t receive a lot of special attention. Instead, they are the ones following you on Social Media or attending fundraising events or service projects. So make sure you are engaging with them on this level. A lot of times your A Tier donors will use these events or postings to connect with the B Tier as well.
- Plan for C Tier: What are some ways that you intentionally try to connect to new people that have little to know understanding of your ministry? Some advertise on the radio, TV, or YouTube/social media. Some hold community events. Some put up billboards or advertise in movie theaters.
#4 – Is there any Accountability?
All nonprofits should have a Board, and this would be one of the main sources of accountability. The Board and the director/pastor should set some goals. The goals should be within their control. Maybe your goal for this month is to categorize your donors, have coffee with 3 of your A Tier donors, and share a ministry win on Facebook. That may or may not increase giving for that specific month, but it set the table for increased giving.
The Board needs to have a backbone and hold the pastor/director accountable. “You didn’t connect with any donors this month? Why not?” Try to figure out what is causing the pastor/director to not follow through. Try to help them. Maybe you need to call the A Tier donor and invite them to coffee with you and the pastor/director? If, even after you sincerely try to help, they still fail, you need to replace them. Your ministry is too important to let it slowly starve for lack of funding.
Useful Links
- My YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/@JeffPospisil
- Series on Preaching about Giving: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gvVWjmr21Lw&list=PLy3_Fkz8_LMqr6yDQwonN5oUcREz0u9nS
- Article by Mark Howell on concentric circles of a ministry: https://www.markhowelllive.com/concentric-circles/
